Decide independently. With traceable foundations.Quality & transparency
VALUE FACTORS · REVIEWING VALUATIONS

Two valuations, two results: examining differences transparently

Different valuation results can only be assessed meaningfully once the subject, definition of value, valuation date and data basis align. Place these details side by side and separate factual errors from differing professional assumptions. Then ask about the effect of each significant discrepancy. Averaging two amounts resolves neither an incorrect area nor an unclear use or an unsuitable method.

Open the fillable valuation review

AT A GLANCE
  • First align the valuation brief and property scope, then compare the amounts.
  • Review evidenced property data, model assumptions and methodological decisions separately.
  • A transparent reconciliation of results is more informative than simply averaging two values.

Do both documents actually answer the same question?

Read the brief and description of the result in both valuations. A proposed asking price, automated indication and market value report may serve different purposes. A bank document may also address a different purpose or definition of value. Request the actual definition instead of assuming equivalence from the heading 'property value'.

The LBG defines market value by reference to the price usually achievable in fair market dealings and regulates judicial valuations in particular. Not every private estimate is automatically subject to all its report requirements. Its separation of purpose, findings and valuation nevertheless offers a helpful review structure. Also record whether a single share, an entire property or a particular right was valued.

Foundations: RIS [1]

Transfer the main details into a shared matrix

Record the details from each document with their source location. The issue date is not always the valuation date; the inspection date may also differ. Market conditions, tenancy agreements or structural condition may have changed between two valuation dates. A current signature does not turn a calculation for a historical date into a present-day valuation.

Review matrix for two existing assessments
Review areaRecord from both documentsTypical cause of a difference
BriefPurpose, definition of value, scope valuedAsking price compared with market value
TimingValuation date, inspection, data dateDifferent market phase or later alterations
AreaDefinition, source, outdoor and ancillary areasBalcony or basement included differently
Use and rightsAgreements, encumbrances, availabilityUnrestricted use assumed in only one calculation
ConditionAssessments and assumed investmentsBuilding work included in only one assessment
Calculation modelApproach, parameters, market contextDifferent income, rates or comparable cases

Foundations: RIS [2]

Which discrepancy is an error, and which is an assumption?

Mark evidenced data errors first. Examples include a transposed plot number, a missing tenancy extension or a loggia added twice. Such points are corrected using a specific document. List unresolved facts separately, such as an attic room's approval status still awaiting clarification. A plausible assumption does not become an established finding merely because both valuations adopt it.

Professional assumptions must be considered separately. Future sustainable income, a cost allowance or remaining useful life may have a justified range. Ask about data sources, relevance to the property and uncertainty. A cost quotation, for example, is evidence for a defined scope of work; it does not prove that market value falls by exactly that amount.

Check the justification for methods and parameters

Different approaches may be appropriate where they reflect different characteristics of the property. In selecting a method, the LBG requires regard to current professional knowledge and fair market dealings. Using several approaches does not imply a prescribed arithmetic average. What matters is a justified derivation of the result that takes market conditions into account.

Ask method-specific questions: which completed transactions support the comparison and how were differences adjusted? How was the capitalisation rate justified in the income approach? What cost basis and reductions in value underpin the cost approach? § 10 LBG describes specific requirements within the Act's scope. Outside that scope too, these questions help assess whether an explanation is transparent.

Foundations: RIS [1] · RIS [3]

Turn two amounts into a specific review brief

Ask for a reconciliation using the same starting basis. First, confirmed data errors are corrected. Then the differences in the remaining assumptions and the extent of their effect on the result are shown. Where possible, change one assumption at a time; interdependent variables need a connected scenario. Otherwise, individual effects may be counted twice when added together.

Prioritise questions by their importance to your decision. An unresolved tenancy status may matter more than a small rounding discrepancy. If significant differences are not explained transparently, a targeted independent review can be commissioned: using the same documents, the same valuation date and explicitly identified points of disagreement. The aim is a robust basis for a decision, not necessarily an identical amount in every professional analysis.

UNDERSTAND THE PRACTICE · FICTIONAL EXAMPLE

Fictional comparison: 360,000 and 410,000 euros

Two entirely invented assessments of the same apartment. A states 360,000 euros, B 410,000 euros. The figures illustrate a review task and are not a market-price recommendation.

  1. A uses 70 m² of internal area and records the balcony separately. B takes 78 m² from sales particulars as a single living-area figure. The shared area schedule confirms 70 m² internally and an 8 m² balcony.
  2. A accounts for a documented unresolved building issue. B dates from before the issue became known. Both documents are brought to the same valuation date and information basis.
  3. Only after professional recalculation are comparable cases and remaining assumptions set side by side. No blanket adjustment is derived from the original difference of 50,000 euros.
What you can take away

The arithmetic midpoint of 385,000 euros would leave the contradictory foundations unchanged. The useful result is first a corrected and explained basis for comparison.

FOR YOUR PROPERTY

Your next assessment steps

Record what you have already clarified and which documents you still need.

0 of 4 items clarifiedYour personal selection

Collect the brief and complete result documents

This shows which question and property scope were actually valued.

Where can I obtain the supporting information?

The respective clients or authors of the assessments.

Complete the review matrix with source references

This makes differing valuation dates, areas and uses visible.

Where can I obtain the supporting information?

Work through both documents together with the original evidence.

Evidence factual errors using the appropriate document

This separates correctable inputs from matters of professional judgement.

Where can I obtain the supporting information?

Plans, agreements, land register and technical documents.

Request a reconciliation of results for the main discrepancies

This shows which difference actually changes the decision.

Where can I obtain the supporting information?

Send specifically worded follow-up questions to the authors.

Reading and checking are possible without signing in. Your saved checklists are private under My area. The selection does not confirm a professional assessment of your property.

REVIEW A VALUATION

Your valuation. A structured review.

Organise the stated facts, supporting documents and unresolved assumptions. Build a review brief with specific follow-up questions. The amounts in your valuations remain unchanged.

What would you like to review?

Each property type has its own entries. Switching types preserves the other entries while this page stays open.

When switching to one valuation, the entries for B remain available in this open page; they are excluded from that review and download.

How to proceed

First copy the information from the documents. Then identify the supporting evidence. Finally review the differences detected and the follow-up brief.

Areas and amounts: no thousands separators and up to two decimal places, e.g. 70.5 or 360000. Result amounts are EUR totals; documented zero or negative amounts can be recorded. Blank fields remain unknown.

Your entries stay in this open page. Reloading clears them. Download your review record before leaving.

Purpose and value definition

What question does the valuation answer?

Check against: Instruction and service description with the result definition.

Ask specifically: Ask which decision the value is intended to support and what its definition means.

Read the relevant guide
Valuation A

For example provider, report title or your own label.

Use the actual definition in the document.

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Valuation B

For example provider, report title or your own label.

Use the actual definition in the document.

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Dates and data period

Which date and data period does the result refer to?

Check against: Record valuation date, report date and data period separately.

Ask specifically: Ask for the relevant valuation date and the period covered by the data. A new signature does not make old data current.

Read the relevant guide
Valuation A

The report issue date may differ from the valuation date.

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Valuation B

The report issue date may differ from the valuation date.

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Scope and areas

What was valued and which area definition was used?

Check against: Property description, area schedule, plan and allocation of accessory spaces.

Ask specifically: Have the components valued and the reference area reconciled, including definition, source and document reference.

Read the relevant guide
Valuation A

For example apartment 12 with parking space; no personal names are needed.

For share valuations only: use the original fraction, e.g. 123/7489, or a percentage, e.g. 50%. Percentages accept up to eight decimal places; do not round the original fraction.

Record the principal reference area and its definition; describe additional areas separately in the property scope. For a right without an area reference, leave blank and explain non-applicability.

Do not automatically add this to the reference area. Enter 0 only when no outdoor area is expressly recorded.

How are the balcony, loggia, cellar, garden or parking space allocated?

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Valuation B

For example apartment 12 with parking space; no personal names are needed.

For share valuations only: use the original fraction, e.g. 123/7489, or a percentage, e.g. 50%. Percentages accept up to eight decimal places; do not round the original fraction.

Record the principal reference area and its definition; describe additional areas separately in the property scope. For a right without an area reference, leave blank and explain non-applicability.

Do not automatically add this to the reference area. Enter 0 only when no outdoor area is expressly recorded.

How are the balcony, loggia, cellar, garden or parking space allocated?

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Data type and sources

Which transaction, rental, cost or model data supports the valuation?

Check against: Source references with data type, period and geographical scope; distinguish agreed prices and advertised prices.

Ask specifically: Ask for the source, price type and geographical coverage. A district figure is not an observed price for your street or apartment.

Read the relevant guide
Valuation A

For example contract dates, data year or publication period.

For an income or cost approach, record the rental or cost basis. Describe several types separately in the source field.

Provider / source and address, comparison area, district or wider region.

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Valuation B

For example contract dates, data year or publication period.

For an income or cost approach, record the rental or cost basis. Describe several types separately in the source field.

Provider / source and address, comparison area, district or wider region.

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Comparability and adjustments

Why are the selected properties comparable?

Check against: Comparable properties with dates, characteristics, price components and explained adjustments.

Ask specifically: Ask how the properties were selected and how material differences were handled. Fixed general percentages do not replace an explanation.

Read the relevant guide
Valuation A

Which properties were used? How were differences explained and accounted for?

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Valuation B

Which properties were used? How were differences explained and accounted for?

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Condition and investment

Which features were investigated and which were assumed?

Check against: Dated inspection note, professional findings, scope of work or cost quotation.

Ask specifically: Clarify the extent of the investigation and how planned work affects the result. Costs do not automatically equal a value reduction of the same amount.

Read the relevant guide
Valuation A

An inspection alone does not confirm a technical investigation. Record the inspected parts, limits and any findings.

Building elements, planned scope, evidence and treatment in the calculation.

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Valuation B

An inspection alone does not confirm a technical investigation. Record the inspected parts, limits and any findings.

Building elements, planned scope, evidence and treatment in the calculation.

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Use, rights and income

Does the assumed use match the documented position?

Check against: Tenancy agreements, rent roll, land register and relevant deeds.

Ask specifically: Have contracts, rights and actual use compared with the assumptions. Actually vacant and hypothetically vacant are different starting points.

Read the relevant guide
Valuation A

Physical vacancy does not establish legal availability or absence of rights. Record contracts and restrictions below.

Name the document and its treatment; a registered mortgage amount is not automatically the current outstanding debt.

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Valuation B

Physical vacancy does not establish legal availability or absence of rights. Record contracts and restrictions below.

Name the document and its treatment; a registered mortgage amount is not automatically the current outstanding debt.

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Derivation and unresolved assumptions

How do the method and assumptions lead to the result?

Check against: Calculation, reasons for parameters, reconciliation of the result and explanation of any range.

Ask specifically: Ask why the method and material parameters were chosen. Have unresolved assumptions and their relevance to the decision explained.

Read the relevant guide
Valuation A

Leave blank if the document states a single amount.

For example income, costs, rate, useful life or the meaning of the stated range.

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Valuation B

Leave blank if the document states a single amount.

For example income, costs, rate, useful life or the meaning of the stated range.

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Your property in its local context

Eurogate - Wildganshof - Friedhof St. Marx

The location profile describes a statistical map area. Its land-use shares and local points establish neither the characteristics of your property nor a price premium.

Open the public area profile
Date the record of the existing situation

Record buildings, entrances and adjoining open spaces as at the valuation date with photographs. Compare older sales particulars with the situation inspected and flag unconfirmed development information.

Check against: Dated record of the existing situation

Which specific property feature was used, supported by which evidence and explanation?

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

Identify the development's areas

Check which open spaces actually belong to the residential development and which are public. Compare communal areas and a substantiated connection to Leon-Zelman-Park separately with suitable alternative properties.

Check against: Development plan and open-space comparison

Which specific property feature was used, supported by which evidence and explanation?

For example: floor plan dated 12 October 2026, page 2. The document is not uploaded here.

Which detail is missing or needs an explanation?

YOUR REVIEW BRIEF

What to clarify next

Start with the information in your valuation. Differences and unresolved evidence will then appear here.

The status describes your progress and document references. It does not measure valuation quality, accuracy or a fair price.

The download contains the selected property type, the current review mode and any local checks. Entries for other property types are not included.

Sources and date

The following sources support this main article. For your specific property, current documents and the applicable conditions matter.

  1. RISProperty Valuation Act: in particular §§ 1–3 and 7
  2. RISProperty Valuation Act § 9: general requirements for the report
  3. RISProperty Valuation Act § 10: specific requirements for the report

Editorial date: 13/11/2026. Examples explain relationships and do not contain an individually prepared property valuation. Editorial work and sources.

Report an unclear point
YOUR NEXT STEP

Use the knowledge for your property.

Open the fillable valuation comparison
KNOWLEDGE MEETS LOCATION

What does this mean for your location?

Connect the professional principles with the location profile of your Vienna district or map area.

Check my location

Traceable foundations for your own decisions. Sources appear directly in the articles; calculations are marked as examples. More about our editorial team and the content’s limitations.